On Evaluating Curricular Effectiveness : Judging the Quality of K-12 Mathematics Evaluations

This book reviews the evaluation research literature that has accumulated around 19 K-12 mathematics curricula and breaks new ground in framing an ambitious and rigorous approach to curriculum evaluation that has relevance beyond mathematics. The committee that produced this book consisted of mathematicians, mathematics educators, and methodologists who began with the following charge:Evaluate the quality of the evaluations of the thirteen National Science Foundation (NSF)-supported and six commercially generated mathematics curriculum materials;Determine whether the available data are sufficient for evaluating the efficacy of these materials, and if not;Develop recommendations about the design of a project that could result in the generation of more reliable and valid data for evaluating such materials. The committee collected, reviewed, and classified almost 700 studies, solicited expert testimony during two workshops, developed an evaluation framework, established dimensions/criteria for three methodologies (content analyses, comparative studies, and case studies), drew conclusions on the corpus of studies, and made recommendations for future research. Table of ContentsFront MatterExecutive Summary1 The Challenge and the Charge2 Committee Procedures and Characteristics of Studies Reviewed3 Framework for Evaluating Curricular Effectiveness4 Content Analysis5 Comparative Studies6 Case Studies and Synthesis Studies7 Conclusions and RecommendationsReferencesAppendix A: Biographic SketchesAppendix B: Bibliography of Studies Included in Committee AnalysisAppendix C: Outcomes MeasuresIndex