Selecting and Retaining State Supreme Court Justices

Selecting and Retaining State Supreme Court Justices offers a comprehensive analysis of how states choose and retain their highest court judges. Covering fifty years of change, it examines elections, appointments, and legislative selections, revealing how political polarization and landmark U.S. Supreme Court decisions have reshaped judicial selection and retention.

How do states choose—and keep—the judges who sit on their highest courts? Selecting and Retaining State Supreme Court Justices offers the most comprehensive analysis to date of the political processes shaping judicial selection and retention across all fifty states. From partisan and nonpartisan elections to legislative votes and gubernatorial appointments, this book explores the full spectrum of methods used to fill state supreme court seats—and the political forces behind them. It examines how these processes have evolved over the fifty years, from 1976 to 2025, against a backdrop of growing polarization and landmark U.S. Supreme Court decisions on issues such as gerrymandering and abortion. Two closely related questions drive the study: How have the politics of judicial selection and retention changed over the fifty-year period covered by the book? And have recent U.S. Supreme Court rulings, which removed federal courts from most issues related to gerrymandering and abortion, produced some of those changes in the short time since those decisions? Drawing on extensive data and original research, the author reveals that the answers are complex—and deeply intertwined with broader political trends. Unlike any other study, this book delves into less common practices, including selection by appointment, legislative elections, and retention methods beyond popular vote. Whether you are a scholar, student, or policymaker, this volume is an essential resource for understanding the dynamic interplay between law and politics in America''s state courts.